More Asbestos Woes For Fashion Accessory Chain 'Claire's.

Two months ago we shared the news that lab tests conducted by the Scientific Analytical Institute had found traces of deadly asbestos in 17 make-up products sold by fashion accessory chain Claire’s.

Asbestos has been found in more products sold at Claire's stores.

Asbestos has been found in more products sold at Claire's stores.

After pulling nine of its make-up products, Claire’s had private lab testing done that showed the products were asbestos free. The fashion accessory chain then issued statements denying claims that their products ever contained asbestos; however, a new wave of lab reports has found this claim to be false.

The tests, carried out on behalf of consumer interest group US.PIRG, found an additional three makeup products sold at Claire’s stores tested positive for deadly asbestos fibres. 

Claire’s has denied these claims made by US.PIRG, citing its previous lab results and criticising the research methods undertaken by US.PIRG. 

The outlook is equally grim for Claire’s stores in the UK, where the chain has been ordered to destroy two of its make-up products: the highly popular eye shadow and face blusher kits. 

The face blusher kit is just one of the products sold at Claire's UK chains that was found to contain asbestos. 

The face blusher kit is just one of the products sold at Claire's UK chains that was found to contain asbestos. 

This order from the UK government comes after Dutch authorities found asbestos in the two Claire’s products. These findings were then confirmed by officials in Brussels which lead to a Europe-wide alert being placed on the products. 

Much like how it played out in the US, Claire’s is predictably claiming that their products are safe and asbestos free, as well as refusing to release how long the asbestos contaminated products were sold for. 

The presence of asbestos in Claire’s make-up is particularly troubling for two reasons:

  1. Since it is warn on the face there is a very high change of asbestos fibres being inhaled through the nose or mouth.
  2. Claire’s make-up is marketed to and predominately warn by teenage girls.

The asbestos fibres were believed to be introduced to the make-up through talc, a common make-up ingredient that is used to absorb moisture and give the product a smooth feel on the skin. 

Related Articles

Asbestos Found In Make-Up Products

As we've previously discussed on this blog, before the health risks of exposure to asbestos were known (and in many cases even after), the mineral was widely used in everything from building materials to roof insulation to break pads to sand pit filler... and now apparently, even make-up. 

A lab in North Carolina, USA, recently found trace amounts of tremolite asbestos in a Claire’s (A chain of accessory stores) make-up product aimed at young girls. Although never used commercially, tremolite asbestos is often found in talc, a key component in many make-up products. 

Make up; not the first place you would expect to find asbestos...

Make up; not the first place you would expect to find asbestos...

The tremolite was discovered when a local mother decided to send a sample of her daughter’s make-up into a local lab to see what was in it.  What was meant to be a fun indulgence of curiosity took a dark turn when the results showed asbestos was present in the make-up.

Claire's initially pulled nine of its cosmetic products as a precautionary measure; however, after conducting its own testing with two different labs, Claire’s has released a statement refuting the claim their make-up products ever contained traces of the deadly mineral.

The statement issued by Claire’s said “We are pleased to report that test results received to date from two certified independent labs confirm that the products in question are asbestos free, completely safe and meet all government requirements”

A spokesman for Claire’s also added “Any report that suggests that the products are not safe is totally false”.

Accessory chain-store Claire's was forced to re-call nine make up products after reports came out that they contained traces of tremolite asbestos. 

Accessory chain-store Claire's was forced to re-call nine make up products after reports came out that they contained traces of tremolite asbestos. 

Despite Claire’s claims, the lab that conducted the initial testing that found the asbestos is standing by their results, asserting that asbestos was found in a variety of Claire’s make-up products and questioning the validity of the tests conducted by Claire's.

This isn’t the first time asbestos has been allegedly found in make-up. Mid last year American chain store, Justice, stopped selling its ‘Shine Shimmer Powder’ after an investigation revealed it contained asbestos.

Given that asbestos can lead to serious health problems, the presence of the mineral in make-up products is particularly concerning. Here is hoping this latest incident is the last time the mineral is found in cosmetics products. 

Related Articles